Small Town Times editor talks with former deputy mayor and veteran former councillor about North Bay City Council decision to punish member following integrity commissioner investigation.
Sheldon Forgette, was 23 when his 2014 election success vaulted him into the deputy mayor chair. His young age and lack of political experience was often cited when criticism followed his tumultuous term of service.
Deputy Mayor Maggie Horsfield, who filed the complaint against Coun. Sara Inch, also won the top spot in her first election run last year at this time. Inch is also a newcomer and her opinion that Horsfield would think differently about certain issues if she has more lived experience, which draws the charge of ageism and discriminatory speech.
Joining Forgette on this podcast is Dave Mendicino, who served for several council terms, agrees with Horsfield contention that Inch’s comments about her were not welcome and should have stopped sooner.
Forgette believes that Inch should be able to comment on another council’s member’s attributes and abilities to protect her charter right to express her opinion, warning that hard conversations are part of political life.
*Freedom of Expression as a Charter right is limited by how it impacts others, such as defamatory libel or Ontario Human Rights Code provisions about prejudice (such as a person’s age and health issues).
Editor Dave Dale says Inch went too far only with the Facebook post that left an impression that Horsfield wasn’t forthcoming with budget information when email evidence proved that was not the case. The post was removed soon after and Inch admitted that she was "too casual" with her words.
Exactly why Inch would question the bias and ability of the ad hoc committee chosen to pick a new CAO is a mystery. Inch as actually part of the motion that created the committee, her "hindsight" email was just not smart politics. The mayor and top three councillors are natural candidates for such a committee, and by pointing out (albeit in veiled phrasing) that they all have bias, specifically two may be unsuitable because they were going through life changes (one mourning for a grandchild and another pregnant) is just bad form. The initial email exchange was a private debate and could have ended by either side stopping and blocking if they wanted.
That’s where it should have ended, in many eyes, because $36,000 should be spent on more important matters. Of course, everyone is welcome to their own opinion on that …
As always, anyone mentioned in Small Town Times podcasts are welcome to be guests for a future episode to discuss that matter further.

Read More Read Less

Life views from North Bay, Ontario, Canada, with snapshots of rural living, sports and politics mixed with podcasts by a long-time story teller. Small Town Times Productions is the name of my communication business, which publishes content for online and print applications. The flagship print publication is the Back in the Bay Magazine, which focuses […]

Rate this Episode:

Other Episodes

Load More

Podcasts You Might Enjoy…

Environmental Impact of Mining in Northern Ontario and Canada - The Backroads Bill Podcast

By Backroads Bill

The Frontline Podcast - North Bay Hockey Podcast

By The Frontline

Coming Soon - Art People Podcast with Joe Drinkwalter

By Joe Drinkwalter

We would love to hear from you!

Please record your message.

Record, Listen, Send

Allow access to your microphone

Click "Allow" in the permission dialog. It usually appears under the address bar in the upper left side of the window. We respect your privacy.

Microphone access error

It seems your microphone is disabled in the browser settings. Please go to your browser settings and enable access to your microphone.

Speak now


Canvas not available.

Reset recording?

Are you sure you want to start a new recording? Your current recording will be deleted.

Oops, something went wrong

Error occurred during uploading your audio. Please click the Retry button to try again.

Thank you

Send your recording